AI Use Declaration

The Scientific and Technological Bulletin (BCT) recognizes that the development of artificial intelligence (AI), particularly large language models and generative artificial intelligence tools, has significantly transformed the processes of research, academic writing, information analysis, peer review, and scientific communication.

In this context, the journal promotes the responsible, ethical, and transparent use of these technologies, recognizing their potential as tools to support scientific and technological research.

The use of artificial intelligence does not, in itself, constitute editorial misconduct or represent an automatic reason for rejecting a manuscript. However, its use must adhere to the principles of transparency, human oversight, bibliographic integrity, originality, and accuracy of the information presented.

Scientific, academic, and ethical responsibility for published content rests exclusively with the authors, who must ensure the authenticity, accuracy, and reliability of their research.

General Provisions

The BCT permits the use of artificial intelligence tools to support the preparation of scientific and technological manuscripts, provided that their use does not compromise the originality, academic quality, or integrity of the research.

Editorial evaluation shall be based on relevance, methodological rigor, scientific contribution, originality, and compliance with the editorial standards established by the journal.

Permitted Uses That Do Not Require Detailed Disclosure

The use of artificial intelligence tools is permitted for auxiliary activities that do not substantially modify the scientific content of the manuscript, such as:

  • Spelling and grammatical correction.

  • Improvement of academic writing and style.

  • Translation of texts from the author's native language.

  • Lexical suggestions and linguistic organization.

  • Formatting and standardization of bibliographic references.

  • Conversion of document formats.

  • Transcription of audio files.

  • Analysis and correction of programming code.

In these cases, disclosure of the use of artificial intelligence shall be optional, provided that these tools have not been involved in the substantive development of the scientific content.

Uses Requiring Mandatory Disclosure

Authors must explicitly disclose the use of artificial intelligence when it has been involved in activities related to the substantive content of the manuscript.

These activities include:

  • Generation or reformulation of text passages beyond linguistic correction.

  • Full or partial preparation of the summary or abstract.

  • Assistance in formulating research hypotheses and objectives.

  • Support in methodological design or interpretation of results.

  • Generation of programming code, data processing programs, database queries, or other equivalent tools.

  • Data analysis using artificial intelligence systems.

  • AI-assisted bibliographic searches, particularly when references suggested by these tools are incorporated.

  • Creation of figures, graphs, schematics, diagrams, or images.

  • Support in the formulation of mathematical simulation models or programming code.

The disclosure must identify the tool used, the sections of the manuscript in which it was involved, the purpose of its application, and the human review and oversight mechanisms employed.

This information shall form part of the manuscript's editorial records and shall not, in itself, constitute grounds for rejection, unless practices contrary to scientific integrity are identified.

Declaration on the Use of Artificial Intelligence

All manuscripts must include a section entitled Declaration on the Use of Artificial Intelligence, placed after the conclusions.

When artificial intelligence tools have not been used in the substantive preparation of the content, authors may use the following declaration:

The authors did not use generative artificial intelligence tools in the substantive preparation of this manuscript.

When AI tools have been used in a manner that substantively affects the content, the declaration must specify:

  • Name and version of the tool used.

  • Purpose of its use.

  • Activities performed using AI.

  • Sections of the manuscript involved.

  • Human oversight, review, and validation procedures.

The declaration must be written clearly, precisely, and in a verifiable manner.

Prohibited Practices

The Scientific and Technological Bulletin considers the following practices to be contrary to scientific ethics and integrity:

  • Presenting content generated by artificial intelligence as original without verification or substantive intellectual involvement by the authors.

  • Attributing authorship or co-authorship of a manuscript to artificial intelligence systems.

  • Including nonexistent, fabricated, or inaccurate bibliographic references that do not correspond to the sources actually consulted.

  • Using invalid or incorrect DOI identifiers or identifiers linked to documents other than those cited.

  • Including references without correspondence between in-text citations and the reference list.

  • Fabricating or altering data, results, observations, or transcriptions using AI tools.

  • Incorporating hidden instructions, microtext, or elements intended to manipulate editorial evaluation processes.

  • Using special characters or other technical mechanisms to evade similarity detection tools.

  • Including irrelevant citations, excessive self-citations, or references intended to artificially increase bibliometric indicators.

  • Engaging in fraudulent practices related to the buying and selling of authorship, academic identity impersonation, or the systematic production of publications without verifiable scientific contributions.

The detection of these practices may result in rejection of the manuscript or the application of the corresponding editorial procedures, including the retraction of published articles.

Authors' Responsibilities

Authors are responsible for the entirety of the content submitted, regardless of the technological tools used during its preparation.

Submission of a manuscript implies that all authors have thoroughly reviewed its content, verified the bibliographic references, and confirmed the validity of the data, methods, results, and conclusions.

The use of artificial intelligence tools does not exempt authors from or diminish their academic, scientific, and ethical responsibilities.

Use of AI in Peer Review

The peer review process constitutes a specialized academic activity based on the knowledge, experience, and critical judgment of reviewers.

The BCT permits the use of artificial intelligence as an auxiliary tool for certain activities, such as:

  • Verification of bibliographic references.

  • Translation of content to facilitate comprehension.

  • Organization and structuring of editorial observations.

Its use shall be subject to the following conditions:

  1. The reviewer must inform the responsible editor of the use of artificial intelligence tools through the confidential comments provided during the evaluation process.

  2. Complete manuscripts or substantial excerpts may not be uploaded to platforms that do not guarantee the confidentiality of the information.

  3. Judgments concerning the originality, methodology, relevance, scientific contribution, and quality of the manuscript must be formulated directly by the reviewer.

Delegating the evaluation process to automated systems without human oversight constitutes a breach of the responsibilities associated with peer review.

In the event of indications of inappropriate use, the editorial team may request clarification from the reviewer. Repeated misuse may result in exclusion from the journal's pool of reviewers.

The Scientific and Technological Bulletin provides evaluation and verification mechanisms intended to safeguard the originality, authenticity, and scientific quality of manuscripts.

These mechanisms include similarity and plagiarism detection tools, as well as complementary editorial auditing procedures.

The policy considers three main areas of verification:

Authorship, Affiliation, and Academic Identification

This includes verification of authors' identities, consistency of their institutional affiliations, and traceability of academic identifiers, such as ORCID.

It also includes the identification of potential irregularities related to authorship, file manipulation, insertion of hidden text, and content generated by artificial intelligence without substantive academic review.

Bibliographic Integrity

This includes reviewing the existence, relevance, and correspondence of the bibliographic sources used.

Particular consideration shall be given to:

  • Nonexistent or fabricated references.

  • References that do not support the statements attributed to them.

  • Inconsistencies between citations and bibliographic references.

  • Incorrect or invalid DOI identifiers.

  • References corresponding to retracted publications.

  • Potential irregularities associated with fraudulent scientific journals.

  • Currency and relevance of the bibliography consulted.

Consistency of Data, Methodology, and Results

This includes verification of consistency between the data presented, the methodology described, and the results obtained.

Its purpose is to identify inconsistencies that may compromise the validity, reproducibility, or reliability of the research.

Verification procedures may be applied at different stages of the editorial process and, where appropriate, after publication.

Results obtained through automated tools shall constitute supplementary technical evidence and shall not replace the decisions of the editorial team.

Noncompliance

The BCT establishes a system of editorial measures proportional to the severity of the irregularities identified and their deliberate or negligent nature.

Minor Violations

These include minor omissions in declarations regarding the use of artificial intelligence or insufficient information about its use.

Such cases may be resolved through requests for clarification or correction during the editorial process, without necessarily affecting the decision regarding the manuscript.

Moderate Violations

These include the incorporation of invalid bibliographic references not identified by the authors or the use of artificial intelligence tools in substantive sections without the corresponding disclosure, provided that the content can be verified.

These situations may result in requests for major revisions or rejection of the manuscript, depending on the evaluation of the responsible editor.

Serious Violations

These include data fabrication, incorporation of false references, attribution of authorship to artificial intelligence systems, use of mechanisms intended to evade editorial controls, and fraudulent scientific publishing practices.

Such conduct may result in rejection of the manuscript before peer review or at any stage of the editorial process.

For articles that have already been published, the corresponding correction or retraction procedures may be initiated.

This Policy on the Responsible Use of Artificial Intelligence shall enter into force upon its official publication on the Scientific and Technological Bulletin website.

Its provisions shall apply to manuscripts submitted from that date onward.

The rules concerning serious breaches of scientific integrity may also apply to previous publications within the framework of post-publication review and auditing procedures.

This policy shall be reviewed at least once per academic year, taking into account technological advances, the evolution of artificial intelligence tools, and updates to international standards of ethics and integrity in scientific publishing.