
Peer review process
All articles submitted to the Scientific Bulletin Journal undergo a double-blind peer review process conducted by reviewers external to the publishing institution, based on evaluation guidelines and instructions provided to the reviewers by the Editorial Committee.
The blind reviewers are specialists, both national and international, with recognized academic backgrounds in engineering-related fields.
Evaluation Process:
The journal's editor or co-editors will acknowledge receipt of original articles within a maximum of 10 business days from their submission, which must be sent to envios.bct@acapomil.cl.
The first action taken by the Editorial Committee is to remove the author's identifying information from the submitted article, as well as the metadata from the Word file, replacing this information with a numerical code to ensure anonymity throughout the entire review process.
Following this procedure, the initial review is conducted by the Editorial Committee within a maximum of 10 business days, during which compliance with the journal's formatting and admissibility criteria is assessed. If no major issues are identified, the article is forwarded to the first blind reviewer appointed by the Editorial Committee. This reviewer will have 20 business days to complete the review.
The first reviewer will submit the requested corrections, which will be received by a designated member of the Academic Committee and subsequently forwarded to the reviewer. It should be emphasized that the submitted files will not contain any information revealing the reviewer's name or institutional affiliation.
After the first review, the author will have 10 business days to make the requested changes and/or provide the necessary clarifications. Subsequently, the Editorial Committee will forward the article to the Army Military Research Center (CESIM), where a second blind reviewer will be appointed and given approximately 20 business days to complete the review.
Following this stage, a designated member of the Editorial Committee will once again receive the author's corrections, which must be completed within 10 business days.
In the final stage, the changes made will be verified in collaboration with members of the Academic Committee. Finally, the editor will have 20 business days to communicate which articles have been accepted for publication.
Summary of the Process:
-
Initial review of article admissibility by the Editorial Committee (10 business days).
-
Appointment of Blind Reviewer No. 1 (10 business days).
-
Second review: Designated Blind Reviewer No. 1 (20 business days).
-
First round of corrections by the author (10 business days).
-
Third review: Designated Blind Reviewer No. 2 (20 business days).
-
Second round of corrections by the author (10 business days).
-
Publication decision (20 business days).
-
Layout and typesetting (20 business days).


